Which House is So You? A Look at the Most Popular Home Styles in My Neck of the Woods
If you’ve ever driven through Fort Plain or Canajoharie and nearly driven off the road gawking at a house, you’re not alone. We’ve got some serious architectural charm in this pocket of Upstate New York. Whether you’re house hunting or just nosy (hi, I’m both), here’s a breakdown of the most popular home styles around here—and what makes them so lovable.
1. Victorian Homes
Dramatic. Romantic. Possibly haunted (in a good way).
These are the showstoppers with wraparound porches, fancy little spindles, and the kind of roofline that makes you question your basic ranch-style choices. You’ll find these beauties in Fort Plain, Canajoharie, and Sharon Springs.
If you’re into high ceilings, stained glass, and whispering “wow” every time you walk through a room—this is your era.
Perfect for: Dreamy listing photos, emotional buyers, and anyone who collects teacups or secretly wants to be in a Hallmark movie.
2. Colonial (Dutch & Georgian)
Symmetry for days.
These homes are rooted in our early settler history, which is a polite way of saying: they’ve been here a long time and they’re still standing tall. Clapboard or brick, gable roofs, chimneys where they should be—it’s like a real-life history lesson you can live in.
Perfect for: Buyers who appreciate heritage, or just like things where they belong (looking at you, symmetrical windows).
3. Farmhouses
The unofficial mascot of Upstate NY real estate.
Simple, sturdy, and charming without even trying. Most come with land—sometimes a lot of it. If you want chickens, gardens, or to finally live out your “cottagecore” Pinterest board, this is the one. Found all over rural outskirts and former farming land.
Perfect for: Buyers wanting space, privacy, or just more porch to decorate for fall.
4. Craftsman / Bungalows
Small but mighty—and usually already updated.
These are the cozy, low-key cuties with exposed beams and deep porches. They’re ideal for first-time buyers who want charm and modern function without committing to a renovation show on HGTV. And yes, they’re as Pinterest-worthy as they sound.
Perfect for: Entry-level buyers, downsizers, or anyone who loves an open floor plan with soul.
5. Greek Revival
Like living inside a museum—without the tourists.
Tall columns. Bold trim. Drama with a capital D. You’ll spot these around old churches, schools turned homes, and estates that feel like they should come with a butler named Charles. Elegant, timeless, and definitely Instagrammable.
Perfect for: Architectural buffs, renovators, or anyone trying to convince their in-laws they’re fancier than they are.
6. Italianate
The stylish cousin in the historic family.
Think tall, skinny windows, dramatic overhangs, and decorative brackets that scream, “I was built in the 1800s and I’m still fabulous.” Found in the town centers of St. Johnsville and Palatine Bridge, often mixed-use or multi-unit. Basically: charm meets income potential.
Perfect for: Investors, entrepreneurs, or someone who wants their home to look like it stepped out of a European painting.
7. Cape Cods
Basic in the best way.
Compact, classic, and built to last. These popped up post-WWII and are great if you’re into practical layouts, cozy vibes, and easy upgrades. They’re everywhere—and for good reason.
Perfect for: Budget-conscious buyers, VA/FHA loan seekers, or people who don’t want to spend half their weekend mowing.
Which One’s Your Favorite?
Whether you’re hunting for a haunted Victorian (just kidding… kind of) or a starter Cape Cod with some DIY potential, there’s a style—and a story—for everyone up here.
Thinking of buying? Want to see what’s out there?
Shoot me a message and I’ll send you what’s on the market right now that matches your vibe and your budget. I’m fun, I’m resourceful, and I’m not here to pressure you—I’m here to guide you.
